PROFILE #0001 · ISVs / AppSource Solutions
Scribe Insight
Once a near-default integration and migration tool for Dynamics CRM and GP, Scribe gradually lost ground as Microsoft built its own integration layer.
- Status
- Acquired then discontinued
- Year
- 2018
- Founded
- 1994
- Funding
- Undisclosed (long-running bootstrapped company, later backed by private equity)
The Idea
Scribe Software developed Scribe Insight in the mid-1990s as a general-purpose ETL and data integration platform. It eventually found a highly specific niche: connecting Microsoft Dynamics CRM and Dynamics GP with other systems, including ERP, accounting, and on-premises databases.
Between 2005 and 2013, Scribe was well known among Dynamics CRM implementation partners. It became a common answer to a familiar question: “How do we synchronize data between CRM and other systems?”
The Rise and Fall
Scribe expanded into Scribe Online, a SaaS-based offering designed to keep pace with the shift toward cloud computing. The company also established a partnership with Microsoft and maintained its position as a widely recommended integration tool for many years.
Scribe remained independent for unusually long compared with the typical lifespan of an ISV-nearly two decades before a major change in ownership.
The turning point came as Microsoft expanded its own integration capabilities. After acquiring Adxstudio in 2015, Microsoft increasingly promoted Common Data Service, later Dataverse, and Power Automate, formerly known as Microsoft Flow, as native integration capabilities within the Dynamics 365 ecosystem.
In 2018, TIBCO acquired Scribe Software.
Why It Lost Its Position
This was not a sudden collapse. It was a classic example of the slow decline of an ISV built around middleware.
When a platform owner introduces similar capabilities into its core product-at no additional cost or at a relatively low cost-the value of a paid add-on can gradually erode.
Power Automate and Dataverse were not necessarily as capable as Scribe for every complex on-premises integration scenario. However, they were good enough for a large portion of mainstream customers. In the mid-market, “good enough and built in” can be more attractive than “better but requires an additional license.”
What Happened to the Product
Scribe Insight did not disappear immediately after losing ground in the Dynamics integration market.
Scribe Software continued developing its broader integration portfolio, including Scribe Online, before the company was acquired by TIBCO in 2018.
The acquisition marked the end of Scribe as an independent company, while its integration technology continued within TIBCO’s portfolio.
Lesson for ISVs today: If a product’s core value sits in a layer that the platform owner-such as Microsoft or Salesforce-has a clear incentive to build itself, that is a fundamental business risk, not just a normal competitive threat.
A sustainable moat needs to exist outside the areas the platform owner is likely to commoditize-for example, industry-specific business logic and specialized workflows rather than generic infrastructure.
Sources
- TIBCO Software, “TIBCO Acquires Integration Platform-as-a-Service Leader Scribe Software” (June 6, 2018): TIBCO Blog