PROFILE #0004 · Microsoft First-Party Products
ScanSource
A $17 million Dynamics AX project grew toward $66 million, missed multiple go-live dates, and was ultimately abandoned after a breakdown between the customer and its implementation partner.
- Status
- Abandoned
- Year
- 2013
- Founded
- 1992
- Funding
- Public company; NASDAQ: SCSC
The Idea
ScanSource, a global distributor of technology products, needed to replace its aging systems with a modern global ERP platform that could support its continued international expansion.
In 2009, the company selected Microsoft Dynamics AX and contracted Avanade, the Microsoft–Accenture joint venture, to implement the system. The original project was expected to cost approximately $17 million and take about 11 months.
On paper, the project looked like a straightforward enterprise modernization initiative: replace fragmented legacy systems with a single global ERP platform and standardize business processes across the organization.
The Rise and Fall
The implementation quickly became much more complicated than originally planned.
According to ScanSource’s lawsuit and subsequent SEC filings, the project suffered from major cost overruns, repeated delays, extensive customization, and problems with the quality of the implementation. The estimated cost eventually increased toward approximately $66 million, while the project remained without a successful go-live after several years. ScanSource alleged that the implementation partner had overstated its capabilities and assigned insufficiently experienced resources to the project.
The implementation reportedly involved roughly 500,000 lines of custom code. ScanSource also alleged that testing and training were inadequate and that the system had not been sufficiently validated against the company’s real-world transaction volumes and business requirements.
By 2012, ScanSource had terminated Avanade’s involvement. It subsequently engaged Tata Consultancy Services to evaluate and continue the project. However, the estimated remaining effort approached the upper end of the previously disclosed $72 million project range.
In the fourth quarter of fiscal 2013, ScanSource ultimately decided not to proceed with the Microsoft Dynamics AX implementation and impaired the project investment. Its SEC filing described the incomplete implementation as having little practical value.
Why It Failed
This was not simply a case of an ERP product failing to meet expectations. It was a delivery and governance failure involving several interconnected problems:
- Underestimated implementation complexity: The original budget and timeline did not adequately reflect the scale and complexity of a global ERP transformation.
- Excessive customization: Large amounts of custom code increased complexity and moved the project away from the standard capabilities and implementation patterns of Dynamics AX.
- Weak testing and training: According to the allegations, the project did not adequately reproduce real business volumes and scenarios during testing, while user training was also insufficient.
- Partner capability risk: The customer ultimately concluded that the implementation partner was not able to deliver the project within the agreed expectations.
Lesson: Choosing the right ERP platform is only one part of the risk equation. For a large Dynamics implementation, the capability of the implementation partner, the realism of the initial estimate, the customization strategy, and the quality of testing can determine whether the platform ever reaches production.
A low initial implementation estimate can become extremely expensive if the project discovers its real complexity only after development has already begun.
Sources
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “Vince Holding Corp. Form 10-K, Fiscal Year 2016”: SEC
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “Vince Holding Corp. Proxy Statement, 2017”: SEC
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “Vince Holding Corp. Form 10-K, Fiscal Year 2017”: SEC
- U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, “Zecher v. Vince Holding Corp.”: U.S. Courts