ERP/CRM Postmortem Files

Postmortem notes on startups, ISV apps, and ERP/CRM solutions - what happened, why they changed, and what can be learned from their journey, within and beyond the Microsoft ecosystem.

PROFILE #0008 · Microsoft First-Party Products

First Line

A Dynamics AX 2012 implementation missed its deadlines and cost expectations until the customer replaced its Microsoft partner and recovered the project.

Status
Recovered
Year
2018
Founded
1983
Funding
Private / family-owned

The Idea

First Line Ltd. is a UK-based automotive aftermarket supplier with more than four decades of experience and a global distribution operation.

As the company expanded, it needed a modern ERP platform capable of supporting its increasingly complex operations. It selected Microsoft Dynamics AX 2012 R3 and planned to go live in 2016.

The technology itself was not the unusual part of the project. The critical variable turned out to be the delivery relationship.

The Rise and Fall

The initial implementation partner failed to meet the agreed deadlines and cost expectations. Staffing problems further contributed to serious project delays.

By the time First Line sought external recovery support, the project was struggling to reach production.

Instead of abandoning Dynamics AX, First Line changed its implementation strategy and engaged a different Microsoft partner through a project-recovery service.

The recovery team worked with First Line’s internal resources and helped the company complete the implementation. The organization eventually went live at the beginning of 2018 and later retained the new partner for ongoing Microsoft support.

This makes First Line different from ScanSource.

In ScanSource, the original Dynamics AX project was ultimately abandoned. In First Line, the organization concluded that the underlying ERP direction remained viable but that the delivery capability around it needed to change.

Why It Failed

The primary failure was implementation execution, particularly partner capability and project staffing.

An ERP customer often assumes that once the software vendor and platform have been selected, the main risk is technical configuration.

In reality, the implementation partner can become one of the most important components of the system:

  • the partner controls much of the design process;
  • consultants make architecture and customization decisions;
  • project managers control scope, schedule, and escalation;
  • functional consultants translate business requirements into system processes;
  • technical consultants determine how the platform is extended;
  • and the partner often provides much of the knowledge needed to operate the solution.

If the partner cannot provide the required capability or maintain stable project staffing, the ERP project can drift even when the underlying platform remains appropriate.

What Happened Next

First Line did not abandon Dynamics AX. After the original partner failed to meet the agreed deadlines and cost expectations, First Line brought in Syscom through a recovery engagement. The recovery team worked with First Line’s internal team and successfully completed the implementation, with the system going live at the beginning of 2018.

Syscom subsequently became First Line’s ongoing Microsoft support partner.

Lesson: In a Dynamics implementation, partner selection is part of architecture risk.

A customer should evaluate not only the software, but also the actual people who will deliver it, their experience with similar projects, their understanding of the customer’s industry, their methodology, and the escalation path when the project starts to deviate from plan.

First Line also demonstrates an important recovery principle: a failed implementation does not automatically require replacing the ERP platform.

Sometimes the correct response is to replace the delivery model, reduce complexity, clarify ownership, and rebuild the implementation around a stronger governance structure.

Sources

  • Syscom, “Case Study - Dynamics AX - First Line”: Syscom
  • First Line Ltd., “About First Line”: First Line