ERP/CRM Postmortem Files

Postmortem notes on startups, ISV apps, and ERP/CRM solutions - what happened, why they changed, and what can be learned from their journey, within and beyond the Microsoft ecosystem.

PROFILE #0025 · ISVs / AppSource Solutions

FantasySalesTeam

A sales gamification platform used fantasy sports mechanics to motivate sales teams before Microsoft acquired its technology and integrated it into Dynamics CRM.

Status
Acquired then discontinued
Year
2015
Founded
2012
Funding
Private company; acquired by Microsoft in 2015

FantasySalesTeam

The Idea

FantasySalesTeam was created by Incent Games as a sales gamification platform.

The basic idea was simple: sales contests were already common, but traditional contests often rewarded the same top performers repeatedly. Employees who fell behind could quickly lose interest.

FantasySalesTeam approached the problem differently by borrowing ideas from fantasy sports.

Sales employees could form teams, compete against each other, and track performance using real business metrics. The approach was designed to make sales incentives more collaborative and engaging rather than simply rewarding individual top performers.

The company launched in Austin in 2012 and focused on a very specific problem: how to improve participation, motivation, and engagement in sales organizations.

The Rise and Fall

FantasySalesTeam attracted attention because the product was unusual for enterprise software.

Rather than trying to replace an existing CRM, it added a new layer of engagement around the sales process. The platform could work with CRM systems and turn existing sales metrics into competitions and games.

By 2015, Microsoft saw a connection between the product and its own Dynamics CRM strategy.

Microsoft acquired Incent Games, the company behind FantasySalesTeam, in August 2015.

Microsoft described the acquisition as a way to bring the gamification capabilities into Dynamics CRM and help organizations improve sales productivity and CRM adoption.

For the startup, the acquisition represented a major change in direction. The independent company no longer needed to build its own standalone market position.

What Happened to the Product

After the acquisition, Microsoft planned to integrate FantasySalesTeam into Dynamics CRM.

The product became known as Microsoft Dynamics CRM Gamification and was positioned as a way to encourage sales teams to use CRM data and focus on business metrics.

Microsoft initially continued supporting customers using the technology with other CRM systems while it worked on integration into the Dynamics ecosystem.

Over time, the standalone FantasySalesTeam identity became much less visible as the functionality became associated with Microsoft’s broader business applications strategy.

The important point is that the acquisition was not primarily about buying a customer base or replacing an existing Dynamics product. Microsoft was acquiring a specific capability that could be embedded into its CRM platform.

Why It Changed

FantasySalesTeam demonstrates a different type of ISV acquisition from companies that build large standalone enterprise applications.

Its value was concentrated in a specific feature and user experience rather than in a complete ERP or CRM platform.

That made integration into a larger product ecosystem a natural outcome.

Microsoft already owned the CRM platform, customer relationships, data model, and distribution channel. Adding gamification capabilities to that platform potentially allowed Microsoft to turn a relatively specialized startup product into a feature available to a much larger enterprise customer base.

At the same time, this model creates a difficult challenge for an independent ISV. The more successful a specialized feature becomes, the more attractive it may be as something that a platform vendor can eventually build, acquire, or integrate.

Lesson: An ISV does not always need to become a large standalone software company to create significant value. A focused capability that fits strategically into a larger platform can itself become an attractive acquisition target.

The Legacy

FantasySalesTeam is an example of a product whose value was primarily in a concept and a specialized capability.

The company identified a narrow problem, built a distinctive solution, and demonstrated enough market potential to attract Microsoft.

Its story also shows how the definition of a “product” can change after an acquisition. What began as an independent SaaS platform could become a feature or capability inside a much larger business application.

Lesson: In a platform ecosystem, the destination of a successful product may not be continued independence. Sometimes the most valuable outcome is becoming part of a larger platform.

Sources